2020 State Dry Bean Variety Trial

April 5, 2021 - Author: balesco@msu.edu

2020 Michigan Dry Bean Performance Trials

Scott Bales, MSU Dry Bean Specialist

Introduction: 148 lines from 10 separate market classes were tested across 5 locations (Table 1) in 2020. In each result table you will find information on agronomics such as flowering date, plant maturity, height, and disease tolerance. Flowering and plant maturity are rated visually in days after planting (DAP) across all locations. In 2020 plant height and lodging were recorded at the Bay and Tuscola County locations due to adequate plant growth. Lodging is evaluated on a scale of 1-5. A 1 indicates that the entry was completely erect in the field at harvest; inversely, a 5 indicated that the entry was flat on the ground with stems and pods touching the soils surface. White mold infection was recorded in Tuscola County by calculating percent infection on each replication ((number infected/ total stand)*100).

Yield results are presented in pounds per acre (lb. A-1) adjusted to 18% moisture for all locations. Small and medium seeded beans were tested in Bay, Huron, Sanilac, and Tuscola County. Large seeded beans were tested in Montcalm and Tuscola County. Following individual location results, yield is presented combined over locations for 2020 unless production systems differ (irrigated vs. dry land), this represents a 1-year average across all locations. When possible this is also done for 2- and 3- year averages across locations and years. For example, a 3-year average of navy bean yield results includes data from 2018, 2019, and 2020 at 4 locations per year (12 site years).

At the bottom of most columns you will find the trial average (mean), least significant difference (LSD) and coefficient of variation (CV) for the data within that column. To assist in the evaluation of these results the entry with the highest numerical yield in each column (trial and year) is followed by two asterisk (**).

However, entries that are not significantly different from the highest yielding entry are followed by one asterisk(*). This means that if an entry is followed by an asterisk (one or two) there is no evidence that the entries differed for that given trait.

 

Table 1. Trial location, grower cooperator, planting date, nitrogen application method and timing, total accumulated growing degree days (GDD), and total precipitation.

 

County

 

Cooperator

 

Planting Date

 

Nitrogen application

 

Total GDD*

 

Total Precipitation (inches)

Bay

Schindler Farms

7-Jun

2x2

2081

10.72

Sanilac

Aldrich Farms

5-Jun

PPI

2127

10.89

Tuscola

Bednarski Farms

6-Jun

2x2

2049

10.42

Montcalm

Jaquays Farms

15-Jun

2x2 + side-

dress

1923

9.68 + irrigation

Huron

Pawlowski Farms

5-Jun

2x2

2158

16.71

*Weather data retrieved from the nearest Michigan Automated Weather Network (MAWN) and the Enviro-weather Program station nearest to the trial. All weather data is from the day of planting to October 1. Growing degree days were calculated using the following equation: ((MAX + MIN)/2)-50

 

Methods: Dry beans were seeded in four row plots (20” rows) that measure 6.6’ wide by 20’ long. Each  entry is replicated four times within the trial with one exception.  Kidney, cranberry, and yellow beans planted in Tuscola County in 2020 had two replications. All trials were designed as randomized complete block (RCB). Trials received industry standard seed treatments, fertilization, and weed control applications at labeled rates. White mold fungicides are not applied to any location. The absence of fungicide allows the evaluation of a varieties natural tolerance or avoidance to white mold when the disease when present. Yield data is obtained by direct harvest for small and medium seeded beans. Large seeded beans are pulled by hand and then mechanically thrashed to prevent harvest loss. Following harvest samples are cleaned, weighed, and moisture tested. Questions regarding the 2020 variety trials, or suggestions for 2021 should be directed to Scott Bales: (989)-262-8550 ext. 2; Balessco@msu.edu.

 

Table 2. Soil test information from the 5 county locations including organic matter (%OM), pH, and cation exchange capacity (CEC). All macro and micro nutrients were sufficient for dry bean production.

Location

OM (%)

pH

CEC

Tuscola

2.3

7.3

9.6

Huron

3.0

7.4

10.8

Sanilac

2.3

7.5

9.2

Bay

2.2

6.8

10.5

Montcalm

1.1

5.8

4.3

 

TRIAL                                                                                         

Navy beans

Black beans

Small Red and Pink beans

Pinto beans

Great Northern beans

Cranberry beans

Light Red Kidney beans

Dark Red Kidney beans

White Kidney beans

Mayocoba/yellow beans

Irrigated Navy, Black, and Small Red bean white mold trial

Sourcing Information

  

 

 

Table 3. Navy bean agronomic and yield results.

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Lodging

White Mold

Infection

 

Bay

 

Huron

 

Sanilac

 

Tuscola

 

1-year avg.

 

2-year avg.

 

3-year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

_ (1-5) _

       %

Lb. A -1            

                 Lb. A -1                 

seeds Lb -1

Apex

104

38

22.5

3.0

12.7

2691

3679*

2226*

2752

2934*

2849

2886

2028

Argosy

100

44

22.5

2.8

8.4

2815

3066

1856

2880

2654

2745

2813

2241

Armada

100

45

23.0

2.5

8.4

3147*

2957

2085

3257

2861

2838

2908

1925

Blizzard

98

-

24.0

2.1

16.7

3646**

2942

2673*

3215

3119*

2922*

2848

2220

HMS Bounty

103

-

24.0

2.6

2.2

3381*

3207

2643*

3425*

3179*

2929*

3125**

2387

HMS Medalist

101

45

23.0

2.3

19.9

3368*

3389*

2273*

3808**

3191*

2806

2740

2264

Indi

95

43

23.5

2.0

4.3

2987

2517

1618

3006

2532

2488

2536

2278

Merlin

103

-

23.5

3.0

7.6

2894

3138

2346*

2340

2679

2497

2669

2193

Nautica

103

38

21.0

3.1

13.4

3033*

3089

2153

2793

2751

2573

2514

2233

Shock

98

44

22.0

2.7

14.5

3162*

2773

1639

3099

2668

-

-

2086

Valiant

101

46

23.5

2.7

13.0

3056*

3990**

2061

3135

2995*

2747

-

2178

Vigilant

96

46

25.0

1.5

6.5

2502

3615*

1961

2963

2814

2680

-

2378

12039

100

45

24.0

3.0

8.6

2517

3824*

2119

3362

2769

2942*

-

2180

14068

101

45

25.0

2.9

16.3

3151*

3624*

2060

3295

3285*

2913*

2885

2241

14080

102

45

22.5

2.9

6.9

2258

3091

2416*

2800

2605

2685

-

2207

14084

102

47

24.0

2.1

13.7

3453*

3666*

2281*

3456*

3214*

2879

2903

2392

14089

101

47

22.0

2.5

7.2

3175*

2477

2060

3020

2686

-

-

2270

15094

100

45

23.5

2.5

21.0

3492*

3442*

2227*

3423*

3146*

2987

3016*

2126

15095

104

46

21.5

2.9

14.8

3605*

3530*

2781**

3308

3306**

3152**

3097*

2344

EX1702

100

46

22.0

3.1

10.9

2183

2753

2179

2880

2499

2376

2600

2207

EX1708

102

-

23.0

2.8

18.8

3175*

2569

1751

3121

2712

2367

-

2489

EX1711

100

-

23.0

3.0

13.7

2876

2537

2217

2742

2593

2439

-

2155

EX1801

101

47

23.0

2.2

6.5

2543

3042

1802

2722

2527

-

-

2297

EX1802

96

46

21.0

1.5

11.2

2566

3480*

1418

2799

2703

-

-

2301

EX1803

101

-

22.0

2.5

26.8

2741

3198

2093

2997

2845

-

-

2631

EX1804

97

48

22.0

2.5

2.5

2870

2497

1572

2752

2311

-

-

2266

EX1914

101

47

21.0

3.0

11.9

2062

2761

1893

2922

2623

-

-

2072

N18103

97

42

22.5

2.2

12.7

2731

2906

1359

3002

2500

-

-

2029

N19253

100

-

25.0

2.2

7.9

3346*

3292

2182

3143

2966*

-

-

2237

N19285

102

44

22.0

2.9

7.2

2999

2206

2085

2968

2569

-

-

2104

SV1893GH

103

44

22.5

2.9

3.6

2889

3249

1552

3115

2701

2401

-

2129

MEAN:

100

45

22.9

2.6

11.3

2945

3112

2071

3068

2806

2725

2823

2229

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

-

NS

617

621

556

399

395

257

182

-

CV:

-

-

-

-

-

17.8%

17.1%

22.9%

11.1%

23.8%

22.9%

19.2%

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 4. Black bean agronomic and yield results. 

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Lodging

White Mold

Infection

 

Bay

 

Huron

 

Sanilac

 

Tuscola

 

1-year avg.

 

2-year avg.

 

3-year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

_ (1-5) _

       %

Lb. A -1           

                  Lb. A -1                  

seeds Lb -1

Adams

101

44

22.0

2.7

7.4

3540

4663*

3099*

3300*

3521

3281*

3250

2066

Black Bear

103

47

20.5

2.9

3.9

3118

4016

2682

3078*

3223

2918

2875

2288

Black Beard

100

47

26.0

2.7

8.8

3684

4250

3156**

3142*

3558

3171*

3292*

1967

Black Tails

96

44

22.5

2.0

12.6

3398

3946

2374

2783

3125

2809

2887

2326

Eclipse

95

44

19.0

1.5

10.2

3052

3726

1721

3245*

2986

-

-

2156

ND Twilight

94

45

20.5

1.5

17.5

2508

3695

1729

2836

2522

-

-

2022

Spectre

101

45

23.5

2.6

4.6

3488

4849**

2822*

3208*

3591*

3190*

3252

2032

Zenith

101

46

22.0

2.4

7.0

3414

3795

2294

3002

3126

2832

2881

2034

Zorro

100

45

22.5

2.5

5.3

3316

4023

2195

3125*

3093

2718

2771

2388

Zorro + Heads Up

100

45

22.0

2.5

4.9

3406

3867

2131

2734

3034

-

-

2421

14500

101

46

23.5

2.7

9.1

4253**

4574*

3039*

3444*

3827**

3435**

3461**

1915

15610

102

47

21.0

2.8

14.0

3222

4189

2843*

3490**

3435

3134

3072

2311

15619

103

45

21.5

3.0

7.0

3140

4653*

2698

3239*

3471

2996

2796

2123

16590

102

46

23.0

3.0

6.7

3077

3900

2484

3095*

3138

-

-

2005

16648

103

47

22.5

3.0

7.0

3053

3940

2454

3096*

3143

-

-

2036

17704

101

47

25.0

2.5

1.1

3069

3679

2138

2830

2973

-

-

2744

17708

97

44

23.0

2.5

11.2

3215

3564

1909

2887

2987

-

-

2125

17715

96

47

21.5

2.6

5.3

2850

4376*

2500

2725

3112

-

-

2370

17724

96

44

23.0

2.5

14.0

3475*

3718

2086

2992

3067

-

-

2476

17751

97

43

21.0

2.7

12.6

3747

4291

2652

3131*

3504

-

-

2059

B13SR1-1

100

44

22.0

1.5

10.5

2636

3289

2111

2738

2693

2567

-

1982

B17220

100

45

21.5

1.5

1.8

3222

4308

2273

2942

3193

-

-

2052

B17922

99

46

20.5

1.5

7.7

2877

4523*

2069

2754

3083

2944

-

2333

B18201

98

46

22.0

2.0

6.0

2999

3820

2433

2848

3025

3163

-

1985

B18204

95

44

21.0

2.0

6.0

3116

4228

2059

2703

2958

2699

-

1982

B19330

96

45

20.0

2.0

10.9

3224

3896

2259

3126*

3170

-

-

2042

B19344

100

45

23.5

2.5

4.6

3286

4447*

2245

3101*

3269

-

-

1860

B3036368

97

46

21.0

2.8

4.6

2646

4081

1744

3056*

2993

-

-

2205

B3036381

101

45

23.5

3.0

11.6

2649

4217

2578

2793

3059

-

-

2205

BL1402-15

98

43

21.5

2.5

7.7

2914

3890

2416

2865

3124

-

 

1989

MEAN:

99

45

22.1

2.4

8.0

3186

4077

2369

3007

3165

2990

3052

2150

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

-

NS

556

533

384

467

266

272

187

-

CV:

-

-

-

-

-

14.8%

11.1%

13.7%

13.2%

14.4%

22.1%

18.2%

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 5. Small Red and Pink bean agronomic and yield results.  

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Lodging

White Mold

Infection

 

Bay

 

Huron

 

Sanilac

 

Tuscola

 

1-year avg.

 

2-year avg.

 

3-year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

_ (1-5) _

       %

Lb. A -1           

                   Lb. A -1                   

seeds Lb -1

Caldera

99

46

26.5

2.5

23.7

1946

2615

2255

3006

2700

2685

2826

1356

Cayenne

98

43

22.5

2.1

10.3

2318

2655

2484

3063

2630

2645

2918*

1375

Ruby

99

43

23.0

3.5

35.6

2098

2638

2414

3251

2600

2496

2687

1594

Viper

100

44

23.0

2.5

26.0

2314

3357

3069**

3747**

3145**

3034**

3059**

1596

16686

97

44

25.0

2.5

40.0

1658

2675

2588

3688*

2652

2494

-

1323

17835

100

42

23.5

3.1

19.6

1428

2335

2004

2948

2085

2430

-

1259

17837

100

40

22.0

2.5

25.2

2185

2511

2619

3695*

2752

2518

-

1494

17839

99

39

24.0

2.6

16.3

2042

2617

2651*

3545*

2713

2458

-

1480

R17604

99

44

24.5

2.0

14.5

1919

2946

2162

3421

2612

2584

-

1616

S18904

100

43

21.5

2.2

17.4

2570

2190

2122

3128

2400

2545

-

1284

MEAN:

99

43

23.5

2.5

22.8

2048

2653

2464

3349

2629

2589

2872

1438

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

-

NS

NS

NS

422

301

294

276

215

-

CV:

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

14.6 %

7.5 %

26.7%

25.0%

22.1%

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 6. Pinto bean agronomic and yield results.

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Lodging

White Mold

Infection

 

Bay

 

Huron

 

Sanilac

 

Tuscola

 

1-year avg.

 

2-year avg.

 

3-year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

_ (1-5) _

       %

Lb. A -1           

                   Lb. A -1              

seeds Lb -1

Charro

103

45

24.0

2.7

14.1

3087*

3765**

2879**

3777**

3377**

2942**

-

1229

LaPaz

98

46

24.0

2.9

14.5

2966*

3597*

2510

3495*

2957

2678

-

1221

ND Falcon

97

46

26.0

2.3

4.3**

2647*

2555

2295

2868

2591

-

-

1270

ND Palomino

103

44

21.0

3.0

23.9

2774*

3088*

1643

3000

2508

-

-

1230

Windbreaker

96

43

20.0

3.0

11.6

1900

2708

1855

2550

2253

-

-

1172

P19103

104

41

24.0

3.0

17.0

3088**

3290*

2659*

3308

3086*

-

-

1318

SV6139GR

92

44

21.5

2.7

11.9

2529*

3146*

2318

3238

2807

-

-

1252

MEAN:

99

44

22.9

2.8

13.9

2713

3164

2308

3176

2797

2810

-

1242

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

-

5.0

670

742

352

391

358

231

-

-

CV:

-

-

-

-

18.8%

20.1%

18.9%

12.4%

10.0%

21.7%

19.4

-

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 7. Great Northern bean agronomic and yield results. 

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Lodging

White Mold Infection

 

Bay

 

Huron

 

Sanilac

 

Tuscola

 

1-year avg.

 

2-year avg.

 

3-year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

_ (1-5) _

       %

Lb. A -1           

                   Lb. A -1               

seeds Lb -1

Aries

99

37

18.0

2.5

18.3

2117*

2744

1545

2969

2344

2118

-

1290

Eiger

104

44

26.0

2.5

22.3

2622**

3119*

3163**

3662**

3141**

2927**

-

1230

ND Pegasus

96

38

26.0

2.9

26.8

2270*

3831**

2557

3640*

3007*

-

-

1336

Powderhorn

93

38

19.0

2.6

9.7

2066

2921

1731

2920

2409

2071

-

1286

Virgo

103

37

23.0

2.9

26.4

1898

2129

1884

3132

2192

-

-

1260

G18512

102

44

23.0

2.2

18.3

1806

3431*

2107

3052

2599

-

-

1202

MEAN:

100

40

22.5

2.6

20.3

2130

3029

2164

3229

2615

2372

-

1267

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

-

NS

530

728

343

339

210

269

-

-

CV:

-

-

-

-

-

19.9 %

14.4 %

12.8 %

8.5 %

16.6 %

27.3%

-

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 8. Cranberry bean agronomic and yield results.

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Montcalm

 

Tuscola

Irrigated 2-

year avg.

Irrigated 3-

year avg.

Dry Land 2-

year avg.

Dry Land 3-

year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

_ dap _

      dap

inch

Lb. A -1       

         Lb. A -1           

         Lb. A -1         

seeds Lb -1

Amaranto

92

34

16.0

2881*

2340*

3425*

-

1701*

-

926

Bellagio

100

38

21.0

2356

2146*

2880

3086

1805*

2495*

819

Chianti

100

37

18.0

2353

1839

3307*

3363*

962

2085

992

Etna

92

35

14.0

3202*

2694*

3655**

3412*

1369

2003

881

Red Cran 172

95

35

20.0

1865

1919

2293

-

1819*

-

831

Red Cran Up

96

35

14.0

2240

1752

-

-

-

-

858

Vero

90

35

18.0

2642

2436*

3209

3165*

-

-

935

16758

90

35

14.0

2967*

2185*

-

-

-

-

1158

16759

95

34

18.0

3182*

-

-

 

-

-

790

16760

98

34

16.0

3414**

2041*

3467*

3446*

1762*

2459*

931

16761

91

34

15.0

2703

2021*

3135

3277*

1434

2109

897

16764

96

35

18.0

3184*

2613*

3163

2866

1771*

2403*

863

16775

100

38

16.0

2690

2725*

3086

-

1677*

-

915

16816

90

33

16.0

2948*

2834**

-

-

-

-

955

151085

98

36

16.0

2942*

2756*

3271*

3506**

2101**

2522*

796

151093

87

35

20.0

2934*

2867*

3081

3038

1794*

2741**

887

14L1203B

95

33

18.0

2788

-

-

-

-

-

829

16756

98

36

20.0

2428

2269*

-

-

-

-

947

CR1704-2

95

34

16.0

2398

1626

-

-

-

-

849

MEAN:

95

35

17.1

2748

2290

3244

3229

1651

2352

898

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

590

901

402

375

544

347

-

CV:

-

-

-

18.2 %

22.5

14.8%

17.1%

29.7%

19.7%

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 9. Light Red Kidney bean agronomic and yield results.

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Montcalm

 

Tuscola

Irrigated 2-

year avg.

Irrigated 3-

year avg.

Dry Land 2-

year avg.

Dry Land 3-

year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

Lb. A -1        

         Lb. A -1          

         Lb. A -1    

seeds Lb -1

Big Red

92

37

14.0

2799

2224

2974

2932

1968

2041

782

California Early

91

35

16.0

3355*

2022

3500*

3184*

1575

1851

835

Clouseau

98

36

18.0

2805

2138

3280*

3322*

1565

1982

793

Coho

101

37

16.0

3026*

2274

2861

3297*

2409*

2409*

1030

Pink Panther

98

36

16.0

3268*

2427

-

-

-

-

802

Red Dawn

89

35

16.0

3565**

2242

3612**

3517*

1712

1945

881

Ronnie's Red

104

35

24.0

2538

2318

2676

3275*

2461**

2603**

752

Rosie

104

37

20.0

1795

2363

-

-

-

-

859

15907

105

39

18.0

1881

2017

2148

2595

2387*

2514*

786

15926

107

38

20.0

1620

1900

2077

2634

2014

2230

719

K17703

103

37

16.0

2786

2291

3072*

3581**

1991

2338*

816

K17704

103

35

20.0

2400

2214

-

-

-

-

844

K19605

103

35

18.0

2164

2517

-

-

-

-

768

MEAN:

100

36

17.8

2637

2235

2911

3148

2002

2212

820

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

572

NS

541

529

413

318

-

CV:

-

-

-

18.3 %

-

22.2%

24.7%

22.9%

19.3%

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 10. Dark Red Kidney bean agronomic and yield results. 

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Montcalm

 

Tuscola

Irrigated 2-

year avg.

Irrigated 3-

year avg.

Dry Land 2-

year avg.

Dry Land 3-

year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

Lb. A -1       

         Lb. A -1         

         Lb. A -1     

seeds Lb -1

Chaparral

105

35

18.0

2193

2296*

2415

3044

1803

1989

912

Dynasty

105

37

18.0

2855*

2583*

3224*

3596**

2205

2428*

783

Epic

102

37

20.0

2728

2379*

2963

2179

2156

2303

776

Montcalm

103

36

18.0

2732

2345*

3082*

3368*

1864

1968

815

Rampart

97

35

18.0

2640

2445*

2766

3079

2114

2281

924

Red Cedar

96

37

16.0

3050*

1032

2799

3004

1652

1855

896

Red Rover

96

34

20.0

2934*

2278*

3250**

3292*

2158

2201

876

Spire

106

36

20.0

1745

2102*

2023

2827

1952

2177

838

Talon

100

38

20.0

2664

2368*

-

-

-

-

914

15977

98

35

18.0

2957*

2340*

-

-

-

-

829

15978

103

38

20.0

2686

2589*

2433

3027

2631**

2619**

848

15981

103

38

20.0

1773

1196

1936

-

1508

-

1124

18991

104

38

18.0

1400

2058

-

-

-

-

789

151011

100

35

18.0

3190**

2196*

3220*

3410*

2084

2343

986

161156

96

35

16.0

3083*

2734*

-

-

-

-

1017

161164

103

37

18.0

2786*

2745**

-

-

-

-

913

181017

103

36

18.0

2596

1874

-

-

-

-

830

K16136

101

36

16.0

3066*

2270*

3171

3399*

2042

2301

908

K19111

102

40

20.0

2762*

2103*

-

-

-

-

928

MEAN:

101

36

18.4

2631

2271

2758

3202

2048

2224

890

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

445

650

390

357

354

261

-

CV:

-

-

-

14.2 %

17.0%

17.0%

16.5%

17.8%

15.7%

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 11. White Kidney bean agronomic and yield results. 

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Montcalm

 

Tuscola

Irrigated 2-

year avg.

Irrigated 3-

year avg.

Dry Land 2-

year avg.

Dry Land 3-

year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

_ dap _

      dap

inch

Lb. A -1       

          Lb. A -1          

          Lb. A -1          

seeds Lb -1

Beluga

104

41

20.0

2346

2201

2803

2760

2171

2343**

841

ND White Tail

104

40

20.0

2849

2109

-

-

-

-

922

Yeti

106

39

18.0

1796

2394

2790

3145

1970

2224

841

K16924

97

34

16.0

3546**

2531

3638**

3871**

1950

2201

902

K19830

106

40

20.0

2942

2336

-

-

-

-

795

MEAN:

103

39

18.8

2695

2272

3077

3258

2030

2256

860

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

339

NS

491

418

NS

296

-

CV:

-

-

-

9.3 %

-

18.1%

18.3%

-

16.9%

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 12. Mayocoba/Yellow bean agronomic and yield results. 

 

VARIETY

 

Maturity

 

Flowering

 

Plant Height

 

Montcalm

 

Tuscola

Irrigated 2-

year avg.

Irrigated 3-

year avg.

Dry Land 2-

year avg.

Dry Land 3-

year avg.

 

Seed Size

 

dap

dap

inch

Lb. A -1       

         Lb. A -1           

         Lb. A -1         

seeds Lb -1

Claim Jumper

100

40

20.0

2356*

2469*

2821

-

1952

-

1260

SVS-0863

97

42

16.0

2635*

2425*

3118

-

2334

-

1019

Yellowstone

89

38

16.0

2843**

2149

3378

-

1993

-

1269

Y1608-14

96

35

16.0

2609*

2334*

-

-

-

-

1226

Y1609-14

87

34

16.0

2755*

2584**

-

-

-

-

1117

Y1702-22

95

35

16.0

2490

2562*

-

-

-

-

1335

MEAN:

94

37

16.7

2614

2420

3105

-

2166

-

1204

LSD (0.05) :

-

-

-

260

339

NS

-

NS

-

-

CV:

-

-

-

7.5 %

5.9 %

-

-

-

-

-

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 13. Irrigated Navy bean lodging, white mold and yield results.

 

VARIETY

 

Lodging

 

White Mold Infection

 

Montcalm

 

_ (1-5) _

       %

_ Lb. A -1 _

HMS Medalist

2.3

17.1**

3461**

Merlin

1.9

20.6*

2285

Valiant

2.1

54.3

2981*

MEAN:

2.1

30.6

2909

LSD (0.05) :

-

6.3

851

CV:

-

31.2%

21.3%

 

Table 14. Irrigated Black bean lodging, white mold and yield results.

 

VARIETY

 

Lodging

 

White Mold Infection

 

Montcalm

 

_ (1-5) _

       %

_ Lb. A -1 _

Adams

2.3

30.8**

3632*

Black Bear

2.6

52.9

3783**

Black Beard

2.7

59.5

3472*

Spectre

2.3

32.5*

3408*

Zenith

2.4

39.3*

2739

MEAN:

2.4

43.1

3407

LSD (0.05) :

 

22.0

912

CV:

 

35.9%

20.0%

 

Table 13. Irrigated Small Red bean lodging, white mold and yield results.

 

VARIETY

 

Lodging

 

White Mold Infection

 

Montcalm

 

_ (1-5) _

       %

_ Lb. A -1 _

Caldera

3.4

66.5

2814

Cayenne

2.8

43.6**

2848

Viper

2.8

54.7*

3822**

MEAN:

2.9

54.9

3161

LSD (0.05) :

-

21.9

715

CV:

-

30.3

16.4%

**Highest yielding variety within column

*Yield not statistically different than the highest yielding variety within column

 

Table 14 Sourcing Information 

2020 Sourcing information:

Entry

Market Class

Source

12039

NA

ProVita

14068

NA

ProVita

14080

NA

ProVita

14084

NA

ProVita

14089

NA

ProVita

14500

BL

ProVita

15094

NA

ProVita

15095

NA

ProVita

15610

BL

ProVita

15619

BL

ProVita

15907

LRK

ProVita

15926

LRK

ProVita

15977

DRK

ProVita

15978

DRK

ProVita

15981

DRK

ProVita

16590

BL

ProVita

16648

BL

ProVita

16686

SR

ProVita

16756

CR

ProVita

16758

CR

ProVita

16759

CR

ProVita

16760

CR

ProVita

16761

CR

ProVita

16764

CR

ProVita

16775

CR

ProVita

16816

CR

ProVita

17704

BL

ProVita

17708

BL

ProVita

17715

BL

ProVita

17724

BL

ProVita

17751

BL

ProVita

17835

SR

ProVita

17837

SR

ProVita

17839

SR

ProVita

18991

DRK

ProVita

151011

DRK

ProVita

151085

CR

ProVita

151093

CR

ProVita

161156

DRK

ProVita

161164

DRK

ProVita

181017

DRK

ProVita

 

Entry

Market Class

Source

14L1203B

CR

USDA-ARS

Adams (B18504)

BL

Michigan State University

Aires

GN

ProVita

Amaranto (SV3709GC)

CR

Seminis Seeds

Apex

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

Argosy

NA

Canada-Hensall District Coop

Armada (13068)

NA

ProVita

B13SR1-1

BL

GenTec Seeds LTD

B17220

BL

Michigan State University

B17922

BL

Michigan State University

B18201

BL

Michigan State University

B18204

BL

Michigan State University

B19330

BL

Michigan State University

B19344

BL

Michigan State University

B3036368

BL

Archer Daniels Midland (ADM)

B3036381

BL

Archer Daniels Midland (ADM)

Bellagio

CR

Michigan State University

Beluga

WK

Michigan State University

Big Red

LRK

ProVita

BL1402-15

BL

USDA-ARS

Black Bear

BL

ProVita

Black Tails

BL

ProVita

BlackBeard (14506)

BL

ProVita

Blizzard

NA

ProVita

Caldera (11511)

SR

ProVita

California Early

LRK

University of California

Cayenne

SR

Michigan State University

Chaparral

DRK

ProVita

Charro (P16901)

P

Michigan State University

Chianti

CR

Seminis Seeds

Claim Jumper

MY

ProVita

Clouseau

LRK

Seminis Seeds

Coho (K15601)

LRK

Michigan State University

CR1704-2

CR

USDA-ARS

Dynasty

DRK

Canada-Hensall District Coop

Eclipse

BL

North Dakota State University

Eiger (G16351)

GN

Michigan State University

Epic

DRK

ProVita

Etna

CR

Seminis Seeds

EX1702

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

EX1708

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

EX1711

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

 

Entry

Market Class

Source

EX1801

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

EX1802

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

EX1803

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

EX1804

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

EX1914

NA

Treasure Valley Seeds

G18512

GN

Michigan State University

HMS Bounty

NA

ProVita

HMS Medalist

NA

ProVita

Indi

NA

Archer Daniels Midland (ADM)

K16136

DRK

Michigan State University

K16924

WK

Michigan State University

K17703

LRK

Michigan State University

K17704

LRK

Michigan State University

K19111

DRK

Michigan State University

K19605

LRK

Michigan State University

K19830

WK

Michigan State University

LaPaz

P

ProVita

Merlin

NA

ProVita

Montcalm

DRK

Michigan State University

N18103

NA

Michigan State University

N19253

NA

Michigan State University

N19285

NA

Michigan State University

Nautica

NA

Canada-Hensall District Coop

ND Falcon

P

North Dakota State University

ND Palomino

P

North Dakota State University

ND Pegasus

GN

North Dakota State University

ND Twilight

BL

North Dakota State University

ND White Tail

WK

North Dakota State University

P19103

P

Michigan State University

Pink Panther

LRK

Seminis Seeds

Powderhorn

GN

Michigan State University

R17604

SR

Michigan State University

Rampart (09434)

DRK

ProVita

Red Cedar

DRK

Michigan State University

Red Cran 172

CR

GenTec Seeds LTD

Red Cran Up

CR

GenTec Seeds LTD

Red Dawn (09363)

LRK

ProVita

Red Hawk

DRK

Michigan State University

Red Rover

DRK

Seminis Seeds

Ronnie's Red (09360)

LRK

ProVita

Rosie

LRK

North Dakota State University

Ruby

SR

ProVita

S18904

PINK

Michigan State University

 

Entry

Market Class

Source

Shock

NA

Canada-Hensall District Coop

Snowdon

WK

Michigan State University

Spectre (14497)

BL

ProVita

Spire(09431)

DRK

ProVita

SV1893GH

NA

Seminis Seeds

SV6139GR

P

Seminis Seeds

SVS-0863

MY

Treasure Valley Seeds

Talon

DRK

North Dakota State University

Valiant (08077)

NA

ProVita

Vero

CR

Archer Daniels Midland (ADM)

Vigilant

NA

ProVita

Viper

SR

ProVita

Virgo (13172)

GN

Archer Daniels Midland (ADM)

Windbreaker

P

Seminis Seeds

Y1608-14

MY

USDA-ARS

Y1609-14

MY

USDA-ARS

Y1702-22

MY

USDA-ARS

Yellowstone (Y16507)

MY

Michigan State University

Yeti

WK

Canada-Hensall District Coop

Zenith

BL

Michigan State University

Zorro

BL

Michigan State University

 

Tags: reports, variety trials


Authors

Scott Bales

Scott Bales
balessco@msu.edu

You Might Also Be Interested In

Accessibility Questions:

For questions about accessibility and/or if you need additional accommodations for a specific document, please send an email to ANR Communications & Marketing at anrcommunications@anr.msu.edu.