School Food 101: The Cost of School LunchDOWNLOAD FILE
June 1, 2009 - Author: Colleen Matts
What does school lunch cost? How is the money spent?
There’s just a dollar spent on food in the average school lunch. The other costs of running a food service operation—labor, mainly, plus equipment, supplies, maintenance, transportation, utilities, and more—bring the total to somewhere between two and three dollars.
This stark financial reality is central to the life of a school food service director. It’s closely followed by The Federal Government’s Food and Nutrition Standards, the high expectations of parents and the community and the narrow food preferences of so many children. Budgeting for thousands of wholesome, appetizing, kid-friendly meals on a daily basis is easily compared to a high-wire act. It requires a near-microscopic focus on where every cent goes, and relentless, expert balancing of the nutritional, esthetic, and financial value of every single choice.
To understand how this is accomplished, let’s look at a meal served at Boise Eliot Elementary School, 1 of 85 schools in Portland, Oregon. Menu planning in this large urban district favors sustainably produced whole foods from regional sources. A typical lunch—chicken nuggets, a whole-grain dinner roll, steamed corn, mesclun salad, low fat milk, and a fresh pear—includes Oregon-grown wheat, lettuce, and fruit. But the chicken is a commodity item, mixed with soy-based textured vegetable protein and other fillers by an industrial processor that can deliver a serving for just $0.30 (commodity foods are free, but schools still pay for the transportation, processing, and storage of donated items). This is a compromise the food service directors needed to make to meet both their slender budget and the federal meal planning standard (as of 2008) that calls for 2 ounces of meat protein or an equivalent as the centerpiece of every lunch.
The next day, a vegetarian chili may play a starring role. Made with tasty local beans that the children relish, it is a little bit of a splurge at $0.50 per serving. The shredded commodity cheese on top, needed to complete the dish and to make the government’s protein requirement, is a bargain at just $0.05. Strategic choices like these show up on the plate every day in Portland, with commodity spending usually reserved for meat, poultry, and dairy items that can be prohibitively expensive on the open market. To pay for this lunch, and all the overhead required to prepare and serve it at Boise Eliot, there is significant government support.
The majority of students in this school are eligible for free lunch—a benefit available to all children living at or below 130% of the federal poverty level. Most of this cost, $2.68 in 2009-10, is covered by cash reimbursement from the USDA. For reduced-price lunches, available to students living between 130% and 185% of the federal poverty level, reimbursement is $2.28; for full-price lunch it is $0.25.
These reimbursement rates are the same for every school nationwide. In most districts, some state and local funding helps make up the difference. And yet, there’s nearly always a deficit. A daily shortfall of mere pennies per meal can add up to thousands of dollars by the end of the school year. School food service directors, who are expected to run their operations like any other business, must act to correct this. To keep their books balanced, most offer in-school catering for social gatherings such as PTA and staff meetings. More lucrative, however, are a la carte service and vending machine snacks offered to paying students alongside funded school meals. Sales of these and other so-called “competitive foods” have proved problematic in many schools, however, as they can undermine student acceptance of the more nutritionally balanced regular meal.